Persuasion · 2026-11-01

Episode 194: D. J. Taylor on J. R. R. Tolkien

Bookstack at Persuasion is delivered to you every other Sunday at 6am EST.

By Richard Aldous · full

Read original ↗

Bookstack

0:00

Current time

0:00

Total time

-31:34

Audio playback is not supported on your browser. Please upgrade.

Episode 194: D. J. Taylor on J. R. R. Tolkien

Richard Aldous

Nov 01, 2026

Transcript

Bookstack at Persuasion is delivered to you every other Sunday at 6am EST. Grab a coffee, settle onto the couch, and see your weekend out with a deep dive into the best new book releases…

This week, Richard talks to D. J. Taylor, author of

The King Under the Mountain: In Search of J. R. R. Tolkien

(Pegasus).

Host:

Richard Aldous

Producer: Bhaasita Athani

Persuasion

Instagram

, and

YouTube

to keep up with our latest articles, podcasts, and events, as well as updates from excellent writers across our network.

And, to receive pieces like this in your inbox and support our work, subscribe below. Bookstack listeners can take advantage of a 20% offer for paid

Persuasion

membership, with access to special columns and bonus

Good Fight with Yascha Mounk

podcast content.

20% off for Bookstack listeners!

Discussion about this episode

Comments

Restacks

Bookstack

Biweekly conversations between Richard Aldous, Bard College professor and distinguished historian, and authors on their newest books.

Listen on

Substack App

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

RSS Feed

Appears in episode

Richard Aldous

Recent Episodes

Episode 193: Peter Bergen on Twenty-Five Years of America’s War on Terror

Oct 18

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 192: Maya Kornberg on How Money, Media, and Violence Prevent Change in Congress

Sep 27

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 191: Admiral William J. Fallon on Decisions, Discord & Diplomacy

Sep 13

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 190: Antonia Senior on the Cambridge Five

Jun 28

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 189: Laurence Jurdem on George H. W. Bush

Jun 14

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 188: Liaquat Ahamed on 1873

May 31

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 187: Ian Shapiro on How Politicians Broke Our World

May 17

•

Richard Aldous

What did you think?

Your ratings and notes guide future recommendations automatically. Tell us what you loved or disliked and why.

PREDICTED REACTION

NeutralStale result

Why this might be for you

The article is a podcast episode transcript discussing a book about J. R. R. Tolkien by D. J. Taylor. While the topic touches on literary criticism and historical biography, the provided text mostly consists of metadata, episode descriptions, and promotional information rather than an in-depth essay or detailed analysis. It lacks the substantive exploration of agency, feedback loops, or creative work the preference rule prioritizes. The prose is clear, but the snippet does not provide specific lived experience or original argumentative content to engage deeply with the reader's interest areas. Therefore, the reaction is neutral with respect to the preference profile based on the given text.

Matching preferences

literary criticism
history
book review

Potential mismatches

lack of substantive essay content
absence of detailed personal or intellectual exploration
focus on promotional and metadata content rather than analysis

How this was scored

Rule: María’s reading compass · v2
Provider / model: openai / gpt-4.1-mini
Scored: 2026-11-04T11:30:55+00:00
Source text: Revision 380 · full
Text selection: All available text
Prompt / schema: reader-1 / reaction-1
Feedback used: 0 examples from your reactions and notes
Tokens in / out: 1655 / 179
Estimated cost: $0.000948
Run: #12

Exact rule used

This is an editable starter reading profile inferred from my existing subscriptions and a set of articles shared with me. Treat the examples as exploratory positive signals, not as confirmed favorite articles or evidence that I agree with their arguments. Prioritize thoughtful essays about agency and how people build a life: learning, feedback loops, creative work, finding one's craft, relationships, friendship, conversation, and attention. Look for specific lived experience that develops into an interesting, useful idea. Make room for literary criticism, art, design, history, institutional analysis, and substantial book reviews. Also consider AI, technology, startups, product strategy, and venture investing, reflecting my subscription mix. Favor explanations of mechanisms, concrete examples, original reporting or analysis, and arguments that acknowledge uncertainty. A piece should offer more than a headline, a trend summary, or a promotional pitch. Do not infer my political views or endorsement from the sources I follow. Reward clear, distinctive prose and real intellectual substance. Both reflective personal writing and technically detailed analysis can fit. Length is fine when it earns its space. As an initial hypothesis, downrank repetitive advice, vague inspiration, generic hot takes, and hype unsupported by evidence. These style preferences are provisional and can be corrected with my feedback. Evaluate English and Spanish writing on substance without preferring one language. When explaining a prediction, identify the specific connection to these themes and any mismatch. Do not give a high score solely because an author appears in my subscriptions or examples. Evaluate only the supplied article text; a title or paywall preview is not proof of the full argument. Reference titles (sample signals; not actual ratings): - For a long time, nothing. Then, suddenly one has the right eyes. - Love is to be invested in someone’s continual expansion - How to walk through walls - Book Review: From Bauhaus To Our House - half the world's writing should remain unpublished - We think better when our minds are entwined - The Hacking Will Continue While Market Morale Improves - the delight of specificity - Why we ended up homeschooling - Bangers from Gibbon - searching for your life's work is a multi-turn endeavor - Why I Changed My Mind About AI Risk - The hyperlocal - The Specter Of Neuralese - Your Book Review: Lee Kuan Yew's Memoirs - Agentic fragments - Average moments of a long-term meditator - a case for sharing your dreams with friends - the best conversations help you hear yourself - First we shape our feedback loops; then they shape us - timing

Exact article input

Bookstack

Episode 194: D. J. Taylor on J. R. R. Tolkien

0:00

Current time

0:00

Total time

-31:34

Audio playback is not supported on your browser. Please upgrade.

Episode 194: D. J. Taylor on J. R. R. Tolkien

Richard Aldous

Nov 01, 2026

Transcript

Bookstack at Persuasion is delivered to you every other Sunday at 6am EST. Grab a coffee, settle onto the couch, and see your weekend out with a deep dive into the best new book releases…

This week, Richard talks to D. J. Taylor, author of

The King Under the Mountain: In Search of J. R. R. Tolkien

(Pegasus).

Host:

Richard Aldous

Producer: Bhaasita Athani

Persuasion

Instagram

, and

YouTube

to keep up with our latest articles, podcasts, and events, as well as updates from excellent writers across our network.

And, to receive pieces like this in your inbox and support our work, subscribe below. Bookstack listeners can take advantage of a 20% offer for paid

Persuasion

membership, with access to special columns and bonus

Good Fight with Yascha Mounk

podcast content.

20% off for Bookstack listeners!

Discussion about this episode

Comments

Restacks

Bookstack

Biweekly conversations between Richard Aldous, Bard College professor and distinguished historian, and authors on their newest books.

Listen on

Substack App

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

RSS Feed

Appears in episode

Richard Aldous

Recent Episodes

Episode 193: Peter Bergen on Twenty-Five Years of America’s War on Terror

Oct 18

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 192: Maya Kornberg on How Money, Media, and Violence Prevent Change in Congress

Sep 27

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 191: Admiral William J. Fallon on Decisions, Discord & Diplomacy

Sep 13

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 190: Antonia Senior on the Cambridge Five

Jun 28

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 189: Laurence Jurdem on George H. W. Bush

Jun 14

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 188: Liaquat Ahamed on 1873

May 31

•

Richard Aldous

Episode 187: Ian Shapiro on How Politicians Broke Our World

May 17

•

Richard Aldous

Input metadata

{"authors":"Richard Aldous","availability":"full","canonical_url":"https://www.persuasion.community/p/episode-194-d-j-taylor-on-j-r-r-tolkien","publication":"Persuasion","publication_id":26,"published_at":"2026-11-01T11:00:55+00:00","subtitle":"Bookstack at Persuasion is delivered to you every other Sunday at 6am EST.","title":"Episode 194: D. J. Taylor on J. R. R. Tolkien"}

Recommendation history

María’s reading compass · v2Stale · 2026-11-04Neutral