The Banker Trying To Save Liberalism

The Banker Trying To Save Liberalism

While poll-tested liberal leaders fell to populism around the world, Mark Carney has done the opposite—by giving liberalism a moral core.

Jeffery Tyler Syck

Oct 28, 2026

158

5

21

Share

Mark Carney on October 22, 2026. (Photo by Dogukan Keskinkilic/Anadolu via Getty Images.)

In 2016, as an undergraduate, I had the opportunity to leave my native Kentucky and serve for two or so months as an intern with the Canadian Parliament. My internship coincided with the early years of Justin Trudeau’s government—when the young, handsome prime minister still charmed the whole world. While in Canada, I developed an immense respect for the many dedicated public servants I encountered, but I became increasingly wary of Trudeau himself. Though he remains the most charming man I have ever met, he also represented the exact sort of vapid, thoughtless, reflexive progressivism that many have come to associate with liberalism writ large. Ultimately, Trudeau’s charisma proved unable to stand against the tide of populism and his government sank under the weight of scandal and a sharply worsening economic situation.

What happened next is not how this story is supposed to go. For the last ten years, carefully poll-tested liberal leaders around the world have fallen prey to right-wing nationalist movements. If Canada followed this trend, Trudeau should have been swept from office and replaced with a politer, more Canadian version of Donald Trump. At first, it seemed that this was precisely what would happen. The Liberal Party

tapped

Mark Carney—an economist and former banker who had never held elective office before—to face off against a popular young Conservative opponent.

Yet Carney proved a more skilled politician than anyone could have anticipated. More than this, he has displayed a remarkable ability to reframe the liberal project in substantive moral terms that help to rally people behind an ideology that seems at serious risk of extinction among voters in many countries. With his unique mix of competence and moral clarity, Carney has become the

most popular

prime minister in Canadian history and seems on the cusp of becoming the de facto leader of the free world. Liberals across the globe would do well to study the secret formula that has made Carney such a success—as well as his potential blind spots.

If asked to

formulate in a lab the ideal politician to provide a compelling moral argument for liberalism, you would likely end up with a resume quite different from Mark Carney’s. After receiving a doctorate in economics from Oxford University, Carney went on to have a successful career in banking. So successful, in fact, that in 2008 he was appointed Governor of the Bank of Canada—a post from which he led his nation’s chief financial institution through the 2008 economic crisis. In 2013, he was tapped to be the first non-British citizen to lead the Bank of England, ultimately being the one to shepherd the UK economy through Brexit.

But though an undoubted financial wizard, nothing in his previous life portended Carney’s greatest talent as a liberal. In an age where liberals struggle to move beyond wonky policy explanations for their positions, Carney has proven capable of providing a robust defense of liberalism on economic, political, and moral grounds.

Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from Persuasion.

Already have an account?

Sign in

A guest post by

Jeffery Tyler Syck

Jeffery Tyler Syck is an Assistant Professor of Politics and founding director of the Center for Public Service at the University of Pikeville. A scholar of American political thought, he writes on the moral and civic foundations of democracy.

Subscribe to Jeffery